Batman #4

This issue, while not particularly amazing itself, shows exactly why Scott Snyder's Batman is so good. He knows how to add to the Batman mythos without changing it, and also understands the character dynamics as well as any writer ever has.

While this isn't the most exhilarating issue, it does some great introspection on Bruce Wayne, telling the story of how he investigated the Court of Owls as a child shortly after his parents were murdered. Judging by thisstory, Snyder interprets the birth of Batman from the moment that Thomas and Martha Wayne died. And from little is told about the period from that moment until his overseas training, adding this story this greatly shapes what one interprets then to happen over the rest over Bruce's formative years. Bruce has now always been Batman since that young age.


Also noticeable is how much of a contradiction Scott Snyder makes Bruce out to be. The idea that he is the ultimate loner, yet has adopted three sons, and constantly has a partner in Robin has always sat in the background, but Snyder brings it much more to the forefront as Dick prods his way intoBruce's investigation of his past. Bruce -- convinced that there's no such thing as the Court of Owls -- is reluctant at first until Dick expresses everyone's worry for Bruce in this latest case. Afterall, he's been on the brink of death way to often these past few weeks for everyone's liking.

How the Court of Owls is attacking Bruce reminds me of how Dr. Hurt attacked him - through his mind. If an opponent can counter and negate Bruce's greatest resource, it makes him much weaker, just another great athlete in a cape. And while Dr. Hurt and the Black Glove went after his sanity, the Court of Owls seem intent on getting at him through his over-confidence and bravado. Bruce knows he's the greatest detective in the world, so why not prey on that?

What I liked: Scott Snyder's mastery over Bruce's character is second-to-none, and while not a lot happened this issue, Snyder continues to set remarkable and fascinating precedent for telling stories about Gotham and Bruce's past for future writers.

What I didn't: I wish the Court of Owls had a more dramatic reveal than they did at the end of the story. Beggers can't be choosers I guess.

Conclusion: Not the best issue so far, but still enjoyable, and some great pencils by Capullo. But an off issue by this duo is still one of the best reads of the week, they just set the bar too high for themselves. 8.3/10 (B).